In early June 2020, Mr. Carlson instructed his viewers that the Black Lives Matter protests had been “definitely not about Black lives” and to “remember that when they come for you.” The subsequent night, as Fox’s public relations staff insisted Mr. Carlson’s remark was being mischaracterized, Mr. Carlson leaned in. “The mob came for us — irony of ironies,” he instructed Fox viewers. “They spent the last 24 hours trying to force the show off the air for good. They won’t succeed in that, thankfully. We work for one of the last brave companies in America, and they’re not intimidated.”
Off-camera, Mr. Carlson could possibly be much less defiant. In a dialog that spring with Eric Owens, considered one of his former staff at The Daily Caller, he nervous that the controversy over his present had made it troublesome for his kids to get jobs and internships; he nervous that his youthful kids wouldn’t get into faculty. “It’s not right for this to affect my family, and literally affect my children’s future,” Mr. Carlson mentioned, in line with Mr. Owens.
But it’s much less clear whether or not the assaults considerably affected Fox’s backside line: To compensate for the misplaced promoting, Fox turned “Tucker Carlson Tonight” right into a promotional engine for the community itself. It changed the fleeing sponsors with a torrent of in-house promos, leveraging Mr. Carlson’s recognition to drive viewers to different, extra advertiser-friendly choices. By early 2019, roughly a fifth of all promoting “impressions” on the present had been from in-house advertisements, in line with knowledge from the analytics firm iSpot.television. That summer time, as Fox fended off criticism of Mr. Carlson’s “hoax” feedback, the proportion climbed to greater than a 3rd. (A Fox spokeswoman mentioned the precise proportions had been decrease, however declined to offer particular figures.) “Fox is basically an enormous loyalty brand,” mentioned Jason Damata, the chief government officer of Fabric Media, a media consultancy. “He’s the hook.”
Other promoting slots had been taken by direct-to-consumer manufacturers that both didn’t care about Mr. Carlson’s unhealthy publicity or noticed that they may use his depth to promote their merchandise. Beginning in January 2019, MyPillow, a Fox advertiser whose chief government, Mike Lindell, is a serious promoter of Mr. Trump’s stolen-election lie, started airing greater than $1 million price of advertisements on “Tucker Carlson Tonight” every month. Fox gave the impression to be utilizing MyPillow to cushion Mr. Carlson: As different promoting dried up, the corporate’s advertisements spiked. (All instructed, by December 2021, Mr. Lindell had purchased promoting that will have value $91 million at publicized charges; reductions most likely made that sum decrease.)
Blue-chip advertisers would by no means return to the present in power. But thanks partially to the big audiences he might present for these advertisers who remained, and the premium costs Fox might cost them, Mr. Carlson’s advert income started to get well. Every 12 months since 2018, “Tucker Carlson Tonight” has introduced extra annual advert income to Fox than another present, in line with estimates by iSpot. Last May, after selling the white supremacist “replacement” idea, Mr. Carlson had half as many advertisers as in December 2018 however introduced in nearly twice as a lot cash.
As “Tucker Carlson Tonight” grew to become extra poisonous to advertisers, it additionally started that includes fewer friends who disagreed with the host, and extra friends who merely echoed or amplified Mr. Carlson’s personal message. It wasn’t simply that liberals didn’t need to debate him, although some now refused to look on the present, as Mr. Carlson complained throughout a Fox look final summer time; Fox was studying that its viewers didn’t essentially like listening to from the opposite facet. “From my discussions with Fox News bookers, my takeaway is that they’ve made the judgment that they just don’t do debate segments anymore,” mentioned Richard Goodstein, a Democratic lobbyist and marketing campaign adviser who appeared repeatedly on Mr. Carlson’s present till the summer time of 2020. Across a lot of the Fox lineup, former staff mentioned, producers had been relying increasingly more on panels of pro-Trump conservatives competing to see who might denounce Democrats extra fervently — a scores gambit one former Fox worker known as “rage inflation.” (One exception, maybe, is “The Five,” a panel present that includes 4 conservative co-hosts and one rotating co-host from the left, which has crushed Mr. Carlson in whole viewers in some latest months.)
And as advertisers fled, Mr. Carlson’s opening monologue grew. Where as soon as he spoke for just a few minutes, typically in a impartial just-asking-questions mode, he now typically opened the present with a prolonged stemwinder, addressing his viewers as “you” and the objects of his fury as a shadowy “they.” Ratings knowledge confirmed that the monologues had been successful with viewers, in line with one former and one present Fox worker, and by 2020, Mr. Carlson repeatedly spoke on to the digital camera for greater than quarter of the hourlong present. Instead of much less Tucker, the viewers obtained extra.